In Mortal Combat with the Submariner by Stan Lee and Wally Wood
One Sentence Overview: Feeling that the Atlantans have a right to live on the land alongside the humans, the Submariner leaves the ocean with the intention of presenting a legal challenge
In his introduction to the Marvel Masterworks collection of the first 11 issues of Daredevil, Stan Lee notes that this particular tale is one of his all time favourites. "I think you'll agree," says Stan, "that Prince Namor has never been nobler and Daredevil never more heroic than in this truly monumental tale", also noting that the conclusion was the "most satisfying ending of all".
We'll come on to that. What really impresses about this meeting of two of Marvel's A listers (at the time, anyway) is how mismatched they are, yet still delivers a compelling tale. Daredevil is clearly the junior partner here - but it's his book too. Do DD fans really want to see their hero get an absolute pasting by a comparative juggernaut. It's the equivalent of an armourless individual encountering a tank and standing their ground and, yet, like the famous incident at Tiananmen Square, the confrontation is not necessarily fruitless.
Why bother with such an encounter? Well, perhaps one of Stan's intentions was to reveal the truth of that little slogan that accompanies Daredevil on the cover page of his comic - that he is the "man without fear". It does not matter that he is on a hiding to nothing. He is a man of certain beliefs and fortitude that demands he will try to resist the superiority of his foe.
There also may be a subtext. Namor represents the power of a nation, whilst Daredevil stands for the law. Seen this way, Daredevil's slightly wavering intervention belies the juddering often ineffectual and sometimes seemingly unfair judicial system that a country can manipulate and use for their own ends. Despite this, the law remains a relevant force and can be used for good means too - which is what Daredevil represents here. Can he finally persuade the Submariner to desist from a destructive course of action, when his day in court ends badly?
I've made this story sound deadly serious but some of the early scenes are, possibly occasionally unintentionally, quite funny.

After travelling around the bottom of the ocean being pulled along by a couple of turtles (or maybe he was taking them out for a walk), Namor visits New York determined to strike a deal with the humans about access for his sea dwelling race. Namor, who has of course spent time above water as a member of the Invaders before this time, seems to be flummoxed by simple things like revolving doors and lifts and arrogantly smashes his way to see Matt and Foggy (and then smashes his way out of their office once his conversation is curtailed).
Karen naturally is smitten due to his mix of arrogance and power, though Matt also senses a regal nature in amongst the thuggery.
Namor goes off to tear up the town, thinking that earth's law enforcement agencies won't put up with this and therefore he'll end up in court to plead his case. DD naturally wants him to calm down a little but is soon thwarted when Namor pulls him into the water, knocking him out and then proceeds to surrender to the authorities. C'mon, splashy, there must be easier ways than this to get someone's attention. A courtcase then ensues, with Matt Murdock defending and trying to uphold the diplomatic rights of a member of royalty. Namor soon tires of American justice and effortlessly escapes from his jail cell (there's a funny moment - and perhaps telling comment - where the Submariner looks like he wants to play ball but this is scuppered when his hearing is put back a week). All of this makes me ponder if Stan Lee had a bad experience in court once before this and had an interest in the bureaucratic slowness of the legal system - the frustration of the Sub-Mariner is certainly well voiced.
What's good about this story is that DD is clearly outclassed in his battle with Subby. Despite this, he keeps fighting on, determined to protect the human race, really helping emphasise the 'man without fear' moniker. I like the way that Stan Lee knows that his man cannot defeat Namor and yet manages to find a way in which his courage is what leads Namor to leave New York in the hands of humanity. The below panel perhaps refers to what Stan calls his most satisfying ending. It's a fine moment that has lived long beyond this comic book, being recognised by Comic Book Resources in 2009 as one of Marvel's 70 greatest panels (see here for the other DD panels on the list).
I was also curious if perhaps Roger Mackenzie and Frank Miller were inspired by this issue to write their own take on a mismatched battle - DD's confrontation with the Hulk in DD163 - though on that occasion, it seems to take a lot less effort for the jolly green giant to see off his opponent.
Possibly the most significant aspect of this issue is that DD has a new costume - the devil red one that of course is what we all associate with the hero. It's also the first time we see Matt using his billy clubs as a grappling hook.
Cast
Matt Murdock/Daredevil
Foggy Nelson
Karen Page
The Submariner/Prince Namor
Lady Dorma
Krang
Rating 6 out of 10